Sunday, December 21, 2014
| FAQ | Tutorials |
   
Text Size

Reviews written by Nogdev

36 results - showing 1 - 25 1 2
 
VAN RAKSHAK (Product)
Bheriya
 
2010-04-01 11:04:47 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
4.5
story 
 
4.0
artwork 
 
5.0
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    April 01, 2010
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Issue No. SPCL-2406-VAN RAKSHAK

So, can I get my phone call...
Well jaante hai mere saath kya hua (aapko kaise maloom hoga ), jaise hi main book stall pe pahuncha, uske kuch der baad hi set bhi aa gaya, lucky me.
Khair, main kya keh raha tha, oh haan review.
Comic ko categorize karna ho to main ise social comic kahoonga, kyonki ye comic seedhe seedhe enviromental conservation ka mudda uthati hai.
Plot
Geez, bechare Bheriya cum Kobi cum Wulfano ke rajkumar ko kya hum mental hospital mein dekhenge lagta hai, pattha pyar mein thoda zyada hi paagal ho raha hai, yaar ab to break do buhuhuhuhu.
Iska plot bahut acche se buna gaya hai, aage ke parts padhne ki utsukta jagate hai iske parts, aur yahi hona chahiye series comics mein. Is factor pe ye comic santusht karti hai, par ye pyaar...

Artwork
Bahut hi accha bana hai bhai, ye baat maanni padegi. Phir coloring aur inking ne aur jaan daal di hai. Par Fujo ka maanas roop zyada hi patla bana diya hai. Aur page 24 ke frame 5 mein jo aadmi ko Bheriya faad raha hai, wo Doga jaisa lag raha hai, iska main kya matlab nikaloon...
Mera maksad artist ko sharinda karna nahi hai, main bas ye kehna chahta hoon ki chooti chooti baatein bhi kabhi kabhi moti baat ban jaati hai, isliye meri request hai ki aage se in baaton ka dhyaan rakhein(basharte wo in sabko padhein).

Filhaal inse kaam chalaiye, baaki review kal doonga hehehehe.

Story Plots
 
2009-08-23 15:40:57 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
3.7
Plot 
 
5.0
Characterization 
 
3.0
Exposition 
 
3.0
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    August 23, 2009
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Good one

Atin bhai aapki story ka idea mujhe bahut badhiya laga. Ye story ekdum fresh hai, I liked it.
Par do problems hai jo main batana chahunga-
Bahut saari spelling mistakes hai jo story padhne mein problem laa rahe hai.
Aur grammer bhi kuch jagah galat hai.
But overall badhiya kahani hai.

ADHOORA PREM (Product)
MultiStar
 
2009-07-22 23:01:25 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
4.5
story 
 
5.0
artwork 
 
4.0
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    July 23, 2009
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Issue No. SPCL-2381-ADHOORA PREM

Sabse pehle, mujhe ye dukh hua ki mehangai itni badh gayi hai ki RC ko 20 rs. ke liye alag series launch karni pad gayi .
Ab baari aati hai review ki.
Yaaaaaaaaaaaar, itni zyada romantic kahani are inko Amar Prem likhne ko kaho .
Seriously, super duper kamaal ki kahani hai, bahut pyaare prem bhare dialogues likhe gaye hai, jo badhiya lag raha hai.
Ek naye love angle ki shuruaat to theek hai, but.............
bhaiya kitni ladkiyon ko Nagraj se pyaar hoga bhai .
Artwork bhi badhiya hai, Egypt ke log wahin ke lag rahe hai, matlab country to country chehre ke badlaaw ko maintain kiya gaya hai .
Ratings
RC ne bahut badhiya kaam kiya hai .

PANCH NAG (Product)
MultiStar
 
2009-07-22 22:54:55 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
4.0
story 
 
4.0
artwork 
 
4.0
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    July 23, 2009
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Issue No. SPCL-2384-PANCH NAG

Panchnaag badhiya comic hai, ye rahasyodghatan ki Panchnaag asal mein Kaaldoot ke bete hai, bahut zordaar hai, it can be a start of a new era for RC.
Artwork accha hai aur effects bhi story jhakaas hai. Waiting for more .

Kitne acche se comic ki story ko fit kiya
Keep it up RC.

26 11 (Product)
MultiStar
 
2009-07-22 22:51:10 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
4.0
story 
 
4.0
artwork 
 
4.0
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    July 23, 2009
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Issue No. SPCL-2375-26-11

26/11
Well, it was truly super over hyped. All fans expected it as big as the best action comics of old time. Plus, it was the first ever crossover of Nagraj & Doga, which made fans way too eager.
But, glass house do get broke, and so did happened .
Bahut english jhaad li, ab review bhi de doon .
Well agar sach kahoon, to ismein 26/11 ki ghatna ko nahi daalna chahiye tha, agar ye ghatna nahi hoti to ye comic bahut badhiya thi.
Artwork was OK, Hemant ji ne accha kaam kiya hai.
Ab baat aati hai aatankwaadiyon ki fantastic fantasy ki, to mere paas ek short explanation hai -
Bhaiyon, agar wo normal power waale aatankwaadi hote to Nagraj aur Doga unko ek do saanp aur goli dekar upar bhej dete. Doga ko bhale hi problem hoti thodi bahut, but Nagraj.....................
Agar RC asli villains ko (matlab no power waale villains ko) pesh karti to fighting hoti hi nahi, phir sab kehte, kya Sanjay ji, kin changu mangu logon ko bhej diya Nagraj Doga se ladne ke liye phir yahan is baat pe fasad hota ki Sanjay ji ne itni badi galti kyon ki .
In short, aisa karna zaruri tha .

Ab detailed review:
Story- Good good hi hai, shuru mein bahut badhiya thi, par jab Dojakh waala scene shuru hua to kahani thodi unrealistic ho gayi, sci fi gadgets (Zehari ki zehar gun , Jinnad ka Abe Zamzam[hey wait a sec. abe zamzam to muslimon ke liye ek dharmik jagah ka pani hai na ?]). Lekin baad mein story phir sudhar gayi jab INS VIRAAT ko us tingu ne hathiya liya (waah waah naate alam aur itne khatarnaak ). Ending bhi acchi thi, action bahut dekhne ko mila end mein .
OVERALL- Story ka idea accha tha, execution kuch jagah se chook gaya.


Action scenes- Poor, bitterly poor. Action ke naam pe sirf do hi scenes dekhne laayak the, ek to jab Doga Lahori aur uske saathi se lad raha tha, aur doosra wo Sikh regiment waala jawaan. Ending waala scene bhi theek tha, but it wasn't up to the mark.
OVERALL- RC seriously need some work on action department.
RATING- 2/5

Dialogues- KISNE, AAKHIR KISNE IS COMIC MEIN SPELLING EDITING KI HAI ? There are many silly mistakes around here man. Kai jagahon pe matra mein galti hui hai . Phir kai dialogues sahi bhi nahi hai, jaise wo 1056 waala . Aisi serious comic mein aisa joke .
OVERALL- No comments .
RATING- kya kahoon .

Artwork and Effects- Artwork accha hai, nahi actually kaafi accha hai. Aur Effects bhi theek hai (wo kya hai ki mera artwork gyaan kaccha hai).

Connection with 26/11 incident- Na, gadbad hai bhai. Kuch itna bhi connected to nahi tha.

Modus Operedenci (ya jo bhi villain ke swabhaw ko kehte hai)- Bahut badhiya, arse baad ek khunkhaar villain dekhne ko mila hai, iske dialogues bhi badhiya hai, khaaskar PM ke saath, very funny, but still it has got a cold feeling..

Patriotism factor- Sirf kuch jagah dekhne ko mila, jaise Sikh regiment ke saath.

Scenes- Plane mein Chandani ke saath Nagraj ki baatcheet ke beech mein jo Mumbai pe hamle dikhaye gaye the, wo scenes badhiya the, acche se executed. Baaki to theek hi the

Doga
 
2009-07-16 10:16:48 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
3.5
story 
 
3.5
artwork 
 
3.5
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    July 16, 2009
Last updated: December 08, 2014
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Issue No. SPCL-2380-SPEED BREAKER

Sabne wahi keh diya hai jo mujhe kehna tha ab main kya kahoon .
Khair, kuch to kehna hi hai....
Is comic ne wakai speed breaker ka kaam kiya hai is series ki speed slow kar di . Par ye comic koi buri nahi thi, kam se kam title ke anurup to thi hi .
Seriously kahoon to artwork badhiya lag raha hai pehle se, aur story bhi theek hai, but ismein Doga ne action ke naam pe apni haddiyan tudwain aur kuch nahi aur Lomdi ka dil tod diya, bas itna hi action tha ismein .
Waise aisa ho sakta hai ki ye comic shayad Thamba ka prolouge ho, kyonki thamba 80 rs ki hai isliye zyada pages bhi honge, matlab zyada action .
Overall main is comic ko sirf ek prolouge ke taur pe dekh raha hoon, agar Thamba acchi nahi hui to ye bhi nahi hogi .

SURYANSH (Product)
Yoddha
 
2009-07-16 04:18:31 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
4.5
story 
 
4.5
artwork 
 
4.5
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    July 16, 2009
Last updated: December 08, 2014
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Issue No. SPCL-2359-SURYANSH

Story- Story bahut zordaar hai, mythology kahin se bhi bigadi nahi hai, saare aspects ka dhyaan rakha gaya hai which I liked the most.
Artwork- Artwork bhi theek hai, face expressions mujhe pasand aaye hai par coloring abhi bhi thodi gadbad hai, is maamle mein sudhar ki gunjaish hai .
Suspence- Super suspence hai, kahin se bhi koi guess lagana mushkil ho gaya hai.
Myths- Sahi se handled hai, abhi tak kuch aisa nahi ha ki lage purano ki dhajjiyan ud gayi ho . RC ne badhiya research work kiya hai aisa lag raha hai.
Overall- Comic acchi hai, agar coloring pe thoda dhyaan diya jaaye to is series mein chaar chand lag jaayeinge. Is series ka plus point iski story hai. A very nice comic . Keep it up RC.

PARI JANM (Product)
Bhokal
 
2009-07-16 04:18:04 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
3.8
story 
 
3.5
artwork 
 
4.0
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    July 16, 2009
Last updated: December 08, 2014
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Issue No. SPCL-2376-PARI JANM

Story- Story is fairly good, mere khayaal se yahan flashback type ka kuch chal raha hai, matlab ek taraf Bhokal ka janm, aur doosri taraf uska Daiwatwon se yuddha.
Artwork- Not too bad but not too good either. Artwork zyadatar aisa laga mujhe jaise bas outlining hi thi aur kuch bhi nahi . Hemant ji, jaisa satvabodh ji keh chuke hai yahan pe gaccha khaa gaye. Artwork department mein sudhar ki gunjaish hai.
Mythology- Theek lag rahi hai. Abhi tak koi gadbad nahi hui.
Random scenes- Kai cheezien acchi thi, jaise dev putron ki shaitaaniyan. Shiv ji ka shraap mujhe bankey ki yaad dila gaya . baaki scenes bhi acche hai.
Overall- Theek hai, but it can be improved, specially artwork. Aur story ko thodi raftaar dene ki zarurat hai, it is going tooooooo slow.

Story Plots
 
2009-07-04 01:31:02 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
4.7
Plot 
 
5.0
Characterization 
 
5.0
Exposition 
 
4.0
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    July 04, 2009
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Nice story

Trendy ji acchi modeling ki hai aapne. Is story se faaltu ki NGO's ke baare mein kaafi pata chal gaya.

Story Plots
 
2009-07-04 01:23:43 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
4.3
Plot 
 
5.0
Characterization 
 
3.0
Exposition 
 
5.0
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    July 04, 2009
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Acchi story hai

Trendster ji badhiya plot likha hai ji. Aur main sach kehta hoon, ispe to kahani bhi likhi jaa sakti hai. Par Anthony ka ismein hona mujhe sahi nahi laga, ise THS category mein hona chahiye tha. Baaki sab ekdum theek hai.

Story Plots
 
2009-06-20 17:10:17 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
4.3
Plot 
 
5.0
Characterization 
 
4.0
Exposition 
 
4.0
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    June 20, 2009
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

nice plot

Trendy ji mujhe ye plot accha laga. Par thoda choota tha.

KAHAN GAYA DOGA (Product)
Doga
 
2009-06-14 03:37:47 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
5.0
story 
 
5.0
artwork 
 
5.0
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    June 14, 2009
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Issue No. SPCL-0505-KAHAN GAYA DOGA

Kahaan gaya doga, meri padhi hui best Doga comics mein se ek hai, iska sab kuch badhiya tha, artwork, story, presentation sab kuch. I'll rate it 5/5 har cheez ke liye .

RAKT PIPASU (Product)
ThrillHorror
 
2009-06-10 04:08:01 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
4.5
story 
 
4.5
artwork 
 
4.5
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    June 10, 2009
Last updated: November 06, 2014
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Issue No. SPCL-2353-RAKT PIPASU

Ghappa ke baad ye ek acchi horror aayi hai. Is comic ki khaas baat mujhe ye lagi ki suspence acche se maintain kiya gaya hai aur sahi samay pe sahi suspence khola gaya hai. Ghappa bhi isi wajah se acchi thi. Artwork bhi theek hai (OK ye artwork accha hai ).
Artwork- 4.7/5
Story- 4.5/5
Suspence- 4.9/5
Overall- 4.6/5

PANCHWA SHIKAR (Product)
Nagraj
 
2009-06-10 04:05:01 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
4.0
story 
 
3.0
artwork 
 
5.0
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    June 10, 2009
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Issue No. SPCL-2370-PANCHWA SHIKAR

Comic acchi thi par sach kahoon to ekdum se main chaunk sa gaya ki comic mein fantasy kahan se aa gayi Sach kahoon to fantasy ne kahani ki laye bigad di, jiski wajah se utna mazaa nahi aaya. Waise kahani pe suite to kar raha tha par aisa achanak se hua ki kya kahoon
Ending mujhe acchi lagi aur jhappi ke baare...............(mera munh band hai
Overall padh sakte hai ise.

SPEED X (Product)
Doga
 
2009-06-10 03:54:35 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
4.0
story 
 
4.0
artwork 
 
4.0
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    June 10, 2009
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Issue No. SPCL-2371-SPEED X

Bahut acchi to nahi magar buri bhi nahi, iske action bahut hi zordaar hai. Story bhi emotional hai, magar mujhe kuch kami mehsoos ho rahi hai, jise main explain nahi kar sakta.

Oye Doge, hud twadda ki hou .

PREM PRATEEK (Product)
Bheriya
 
2009-06-10 03:37:17 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
4.0
story 
 
4.0
artwork 
 
4.0
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    June 10, 2009
Last updated: November 06, 2014
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Issue No. SPCL-2369-PREM PRATEEK

Ab to main bhi ub gaya hoon yaar, itni lambi to nahi honi chahiye koi bhi series.
Story- Average
Bas chaar hi baatein dhyaan kheenchati hai, ek Jane ka super shakkipan, Bheriya ka Sukanya ke prati pyaar (saajish bhi ho sakti hai takaliyon ki ), uska mangetar (mujhe nahi pata tha Jane ka koi mangetar bhi hai ) aur Kajiranga .

Artwork- Kya kisi ke paas ulti karne waala smiley hai
Mujhe to ab bechari jane pe daya aane lagi hai, uske chehre ke saath itna khilwaad ho raha hai ki kabhi kabhi sochta hoon, kya itni baar apni surgery Micheal Jackson ne bhi karwai hogi apni naak ki jitni baar jane ki face surgery ho gayi hai . Phir aise artwork mein mazaa kahan. Bahut hi sadharan si thi.

Lambai- Ye series kab khatam hogi
Are bhagwaan ke liye koi is series ko khatam karo . Agar khatam nahi kar sakte to kam se kam choota to karo .

Overall mujhe mazaa nahi aaya, dekha jaaye to kahani monotonic ho gayi hai ab. Baar baar jane ka shaq aur bheriya bechare ki use manane ki koshish (nakaam koshish).

PRATHAM BHOKAL (Product)
Bhokal
 
2009-06-10 03:28:16 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
3.5
story 
 
3.5
artwork 
 
3.5
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    June 10, 2009
Last updated: December 08, 2014
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Issue No. SPCL-2358-PRATHAM BHOKAL

Ye ek aur mythological comic aayi hai is set ki aur isne mujhe kuch jagah confuse kiya hai .
Jaise agar aapne dhyaan dya ho to saptarishi jis sitaron pe baithte hai wo jet plane ki tarah hai (page 4, frame 1). Ajeeb laga.
Phir story thodi si awkward hai aur jaisa rahul bhai keh chuke hai, artwork bahut dark tha, dhoop mein baithkar padhenge tab kuch dikhega .
Overall theek hi thi.
Artwork- 6/10
Story- 7/10
Overall- 7/10

AARAMBH (Product)
Yoddha
 
2009-06-10 03:18:24 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
4.8
story 
 
5.0
artwork 
 
4.5
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    June 10, 2009
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Issue No. SPCL-2356-AARAMBH

Aarambh, sach mein ek badhiya kahani ka aarambh hai Is kahani mein mujhe koi flaws nazar nahi aaye.
Kahani bahut hi acchi hai aur mythologicals ko acche se present kiya gaya hai jiski wajah se ye kisi bhi prakaar se ajeeb nahi lag rahi hai. Yoddha ki kahani ko acche se fit kiya gaya hai.
Artwork accha hai par chehron ko agar main sach kahoon to monotonous look diya gaya hai. Matlab sab ke sab ek hi jaise lag rahe hai (bacche nahi bade log ). But still, it's a good try from a new artist (agar ye naye hai to )
Baaki to sab accha hai hi, upar ke points jo doosron ne diye hai unse main sehmat hoon.
Artwork aur coloring pe mehnat ki zarurat hai.

Story Plots
 
2009-05-25 15:11:24 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
4.3
Plot 
 
4.0
Characterization 
 
5.0
Exposition 
 
4.0
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    May 25, 2009
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Very good

Dk ji, aapne acchi story likhi hai par ye thodi si zyada hi Ramayana se inspired lagi mujhe. Par Nagraj-Naagrani-Visarpi ka trikoda aapne acche se dikhaya hai. Waiting for part two.

KUKDUKU (Product)
Bankeylal
 
2009-05-23 13:19:58 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
1.8
story 
 
2.0
artwork 
 
1.5
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    May 23, 2009
Last updated: November 20, 2014
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Issue No. SPCL-2364-KUKDUKU

Kamaal hai, kisi ne ye topic banaya hi nahi. Khair main hi bana deta hoon .
Frankly speaking, ye comic acchi nahi thi. Artwork theek tha par story mein loccha laga mujhe. Mera matlab anda aur murgi ka chakkar to comic se lagbhag gaayab hi raha, sirf surya dev hi rahe.
Story- 2.5/5
Art- 4/5
Comedy- 1/5
Anda- 1/5
Murgi- 2/5

EXPRESS WAY (Product)
Doga
 
2009-05-23 13:02:11 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
4.3
story 
 
5.0
artwork 
 
3.5
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    May 23, 2009
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Issue No. SPCL-2363-EXPRESS WAY

Ye comic theek thaak thi, shuru ke pages mein artwork bacche ka banaya hua lag raha tha (artist ji, maaf kijiyega ). Story bhi theek hi thi. Lekin stunts bade zordaar the .

AANKH MICHOLI (Product)
Nagraj
 
2009-05-23 12:58:32 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
5.0
story 
 
5.0
artwork 
 
5.0
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    May 23, 2009
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Issue No. SPCL-2365-AANKH MICHOLI

Yaaron, aaj hi mujhe naya set mila aur ant mein maine ye comic padhi. Aur mujhe khushi hui ki maine ye kiya, kyonki sabse badhiya cheez agar ant mein mile to party ka mazaa aa jaata hai. Itni acchi ye comic thi ki kya kahoon, munh se bas waah hi nikli. Kamaal ke action scenes, Nagraj ke mann ka antardwanda, yahan tak ki Jhappi ki dhokhebaazi bhi sab ekdum kamaal ka tha. Bas Silviano ka role thoda kum tha. Par aisi superb comic mein ye chooti moti cheezein chalti rehti hai

AAKHRI DHRUVA (Product)
SCD
 
2009-05-23 12:52:25 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
4.8
story 
 
4.5
artwork 
 
5.0
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    May 23, 2009
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Issue No. SPCL-2372-AAKHRI DHRUVA

Dhruva ki ye comic acchi thi, aur story mein bhi koi loop hole nahi raha. Sabse acchi baat to ye thi ki story aaraam se nipat gayi, ye na hua ki saari story ek jhatke mein khatm (jo ki aajkal RC ki gadbad aadat ban gayi hai ). Khair, all ends that end's well. Ant accha tha isliye pichli comic ki har ek kasar nikal gayi.

Story Plots
 
2009-05-15 14:38:04 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
4.0
Plot 
 
4.0
Characterization 
 
4.0
Exposition 
 
4.0
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    May 15, 2009
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Bhai kamaal hai

Sabse pehli baat, aap apni hi story mein review nahi de sakte lol.
Doosri, ye waali story bhi acchi hai, is baar loopholes nahi the par story thodi jaldi mein nipta di aapne end mein. Bas ek baat kahunga, aap apna time lijiye story likhne mein, lambi ho jaaye to koi baat nahi, bas quality story likhiye :D.
All the best.

Story Plots
 
2009-05-13 15:55:08 Rahul Yadav
Overall rating 
 
2.3
Plot 
 
4.0
Characterization 
 
2.0
Exposition 
 
1.0
Nogdev Reviewed by Nogdev    May 13, 2009
Top 500 Reviewer  -  

Kuch mazaa nahi aaya :(

Atin bhai, kahani acchi thi par kai baatein badi ajeeb lagi, jaise Nagraj sukshma sarpon ki madad se kaise bach gaya? Wo bhi to jeevit prani hai. Phir ye kahani bhi badi jaldbaazi mein niptai gayi hai.
Aasha hai ki is kahani ko aap expand karenge.

36 results - showing 1 - 25 1 2
Powered by JReviews